Condiments Cook with Essential Oils Dairy Free Healthy Low Carb Sauces, Seasonings and Condiments Sugar-Free

Homemade Mayonnaise

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Yield: 2 Cups | Total Time: 20 Minutes

You know that moment when you go to make a sandwich and you realize…..

where’s the mayo?

Which begs the question…..

“Got Mayo?”

Dum dum dummmmm……

“No! I don’t! Now what do I do? I’ve only got 30 minutes before I have to be out the door and I need to finish the potato salad I promised to bring to the potluck that begins in one hour!”

Well, I’ve had moments like this, and recently that moment happened during the middle of a snowstorm when all I wanted to do was make myself an egg salad sandwich. As you may know from watching my videos, my husband Mark and I live so far out in the country that we don’t even have garbage or recycling pick-up. (Translation: Winter Storm = Where Did The Road Go?) I’ve been saving all the glass jars, however, and thought… maybe I can use one to fill with some homemade mayonnaise!


How to make homemade mayonnaise?

Now you might be thinking that learning how to make mayo at home is going to be hard. Like, how do you make mayonnaise? I thought it would be hard, too, but it really isn’t – unless you struggle with patience because getting a great quality homemade mayo that isn’t goopy will take about 15 minutes of your time – and some elbow grease if you don’t have an electric stand mixer. (Which is great if you can’t get to the gym because of, you know…. snowstorm….)

Fresh mayonnaise is mostly made up of egg and oil. Those two don’t typically mix all that well unless you emulsify them. This is where the lengthy and high speed whisking comes in – lengthy because you only want to add the oil one drop at a time (very important for that light and creamy texture that makes mayo so spreadable) and high speed because you want to add air while doing it.

While egg and oil make a great mayo base, they don’t have a lot of flavor on their own. That is why even the most simple mayonnaise recipe is flavored with other stuff like vinegar, lemon, and mustard. (It should be, anyway. Have you read the ingredient label on the store bought stuff? The ingredients used to make mayonnaise should never sound like a lesson in chemistry.) Vinegar, lemon and mustard give this homemade mayonnaise that characteristic tang that makes mayo so yummy. Its for this reason you can probably make your own mayo right now because these basic ingredients are things most people already have in the kitchen or pantry (which is great news if you are snowed in and really want that egg salad sandwich!)

Now for anyone who knows me well, you know that I can’t just stick to basic when it comes to recipes. I dug around my pantry and found apple cider vinegar, so of course I had to throw that in there because, you know, it’s healthy, as is mayo made with olive oil… so I added that in there, too. I will sometimes sweeten the tangy bite a little bit by using honey dijon mustard, but feel free to use regular or plain dijon if you have it. Any mustard will do, it all depends on your preference.

Now for the sriracha… don’t omit it. Six drops won’t make your diy mayonnaise taste spicy, but they will round out the acid just right. Of course, you can add as much as you like, especially if you like things hot. I just prefer to add more flavors as I use the mayo for various recipes, like my Germaniana potato salad or Dilly-Horse Tartar Sauce – which goes great with my 30-Minute Amazing Cod Dinner. (I think I’ve just made my dinner menu tonight simply with the act of creating this mayonnaise recipe!)

Still not convinced on how easy it is to make your own mayonnaise at home? Watch me making this mayo in the video below. I think that making this video was actually harder than making mayo by hand! This recipe comes together so fast that there was no time for second, third (or thirtieth) takes on this one, which means that Felix’s mad dash out of the room behind me had to stay in the final cut…

Gotta luv ‘dem!

Homemade Mayonnaise

Total Time: 20 Minutes


  • egg
  • 3/4 cup vegetable oil
  • 1/4 cup olive oil
  • 4 drops lemon essential oil (or 1-2 tablespoons lemon juice)
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 1 tablespoon white vinegar
  • 1 tablespoon apple cider vinegar
  • 6 drops hot pepper sauce
  • 1 1/2 tablespoons dijon mustard


1. Place the egg in the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the whisk attachment. Beat the egg at high speed until pale and frothy, about 3 minutes.

How To Make Mayo At Home

2. Combine the vegetable and olive oils in a measuring cup that has a pour spout. With the mixer running, begin adding the oil to the egg one drop at a time. This may seem tedious, but adding the oil only one drop at a time will enable it to emulsify, giving the mayonnaise its light, fluffy texture. If you add the oil too fast, your mayonnaise will end up more like a soup that will eventually separate. Yuck! After adding about a 3rd of the oil, you may increase the drops to a very thin stream, backing off every few seconds to give the oil time to suspend into the mixture properly. As you keep this up, the mixture will begin to resemble mayonnaise. This whole process of adding the oil will take about 15 minutes. Be patient – you can’t rush this step!

Making Mayo

3. Once the oil is completely added to the mayonnaise, continue to whisk on high speed for another minute. While the mixer is still running at high speed, add the essential oil, salt, vinegars, hot pepper sauce, and mustard. Allow several seconds to pass in between each ingredient so that they don’t deflate the mayonnaise.

4. Stop the mixer and transfer the mayonnaise to a small glass jar with a tight fitting lid. The mayonnaise should be a pale yellow color. Store in the refrigerator until ready to use (the mayonnaise will firm up even more as it cools).

Fresh Mayonnaise

5. Serve as you would store-bought mayo; on sandwiches, in dressings, in salads, in mashed potatoes, in sauces… etc…

Simple Mayonnaise

How Do You Make Mayonnaise?
Like this recipe? Share the love! 
Made this recipe? Let me know how it went!

%d bloggers like this: